There are no characters in Kinatay nor an engaging plot (unless you consider a series of languid non-events as entertaining) nor any emotional impact apart from the mild annoyance at the barrage of filth, noise and ugliness. Yet these are far from the reasons why Kinatay (The Execution of P) fails as a film. The biggest flaw is in the filmmakers’ unrelenting insistence on shoving down our throats their apparently profound ideas and messages about Philippine society, even to the point where they dictate and manipulate what we should feel and think as audiences. The most puke-worthy parts of the 105-minute film were not the gory, violent scenes but the ones where subtlety gets thrown out of the window in place of supposedly strong visual imagery, such as that shot where a truck of pigs gets juxtaposed with a police car. Yes, cops are pigs! We get it, okay!
On a positive note, the invitation to the premiere gave us a chance to gaze upon a massive constellation of stars that includes (in descending order of starstruckability for me): Alessandra de Rossi, Vangie Labalan, Ketchup Eusebio, John Regala, Liza Ranillo, Mercedes Cabral, Coco Martin, Ma. Isabel Lopez, Ricky Lo, Jake Cuenca, Pen Medina, Ping Medina, Direk Paul of Toni Gonzaga, Jhong Hilario, Lino Cayetano, Ejay Falcon, Deo Endrinal, Lucy Torres, Richard Gomez and that supporting actress from Tayong Dalawa.






